If you’ve walked through the toy aisle of a big-box retailer lately, you know the one, with the flickering fluorescent lights and the half-crushed boxes, you might have noticed something strange happening. The DC section is looking a little... well, younger.
For the last few years, the shelf has been a battleground. On one side, you had the 7-inch, gritty, hyper-detailed figures from McFarlane Toys. On the other, the 4-inch "play" toys from Spin Master. It was a clear divide: the cool stuff for the shelf-space-owning adults and the "throw it in the sandbox" stuff for the kids.
But there’s a massive shift coming in late 2026, and the rumors are already swirling like a Gotham City fog. Mattel is back in the DC game: and while the headlines talk about "global licensing," the reality for collectors like us is a lot more complicated.
At Grown Up Kids, we don’t just sell plastic. We sell those pieces of your childhood that you can finally afford to treat with respect. So, let’s get blunt about what this Mattel/McFarlane split actually means for your collection, your wallet, and that sweet, sweet shelf space.
The Mattel Takeover: Nostalgia or Just "Toyish"?
Mattel is a titan. They gave us the DC Universe Classics back in the day, which many still consider the gold standard. But let’s be honest: that was a different era of toy making. If we look at what Mattel is doing right now: specifically their WWE lines: there’s a valid concern among the "hardcore" crowd.
My boss, William, puts it best: Mattel’s recent output often feels a bit "toy-like" compared to the high-art sculpts we’ve been getting from Todd McFarlane.
Don't get me wrong, Mattel knows how to make a durable figure. But when you’re an adult collector, you aren't looking for "durable." You’re looking for the texture of a cape, the weathered look of tactical armor, and a face sculpt that doesn’t look like it’s made of processed cheese.
The new "DC Core" line that Mattel is rolling out is clearly aimed at the 6-to-10-year-old demographic. They’re bright, they’re simple, and they’re priced to be an impulse buy for a parent who just wants their kid to stop crying in the cereal aisle.
Why McFarlane is Still the King of the Shelf
Since 2020, McFarlane Toys has been the reason DC collectors have stayed excited. Todd McFarlane is a "collector first" kind of guy, and it shows. The 7-inch scale might have annoyed some of the old 6-inch purists at first, but once you see the sheer presence of a DC Multiverse Gold Label Batman on a display stand, there’s no going back.
What McFarlane does better than almost anyone: including the big-box giants: is variety and detail. They aren't just giving us "Batman in a blue suit" for the 50th time. They’re giving us the weird stuff. The Dark Nights: Metal stuff. The Gold Label Lex Luthor in a Power Suit looking like a god-emperor.
These figures aren't just toys; they’re mini statues that happen to have 22 points of articulation. When you hold a McFarlane figure, it has heft. The plastic feels different: it’s matte, it’s textured, and it doesn't have that "greasy" sheen you find on a lot of mass-market Mattel products.
The 2026 Pivot: What Happens to the "Multiverse"?
Here is the part where I have to be blunt: Mattel’s new contract, which officially kicks off in the second half of 2026, explicitly includes "adult collectibles."
Does this mean McFarlane is done? Not necessarily. But it does mean the "DC Multiverse" as we know it is entering its sunset phase. Whether McFarlane keeps a smaller piece of the pie or Mattel takes over the "premium" 6-inch space, we are looking at a finite era of collecting.
And in the world of toys, finite means valuable.
The High-End Alternatives Serious Collectors Are Already Chasing
This is the other side of the conversation that a lot of casual coverage misses — McFarlane may hold the "collector" lane on paper, but for a chunk of serious DC fans, it still doesn’t go far enough.
That sounds harsh, but it’s true. For some collectors, the 7-inch scale is still a dealbreaker because it doesn’t blend cleanly with 6-inch shelves built around Marvel Legends, imports, and older DC lines. For others, it’s the engineering choices — the infamous "rubber diaper" diaper-style hip pieces, the stiff proportions, the occasional awkward posing — that keep McFarlane from feeling truly premium.
And that’s exactly where the boutique brands have stepped in.
Mezco’s One:12 Collective line is probably the clearest "step up" for fans who want their figures to feel like a luxury product instead of just a really good mass retail release. The big difference is the use of soft goods — real fabric clothing, layered costumes, wired capes, and mixed materials that make the figure feel way more lifelike on a shelf. When Mezco nails a Batman, a Joker, or a tactical character, it hits different. It looks less like a toy and more like a scaled-down costume piece with articulation hidden underneath.
Then you’ve got Mafex and Revoltech Amazing Yamaguchi, which are basically catnip for collectors who care about pose range, silhouette, and comic-accurate proportions. Mafex has built a reputation on clean sculpting, strong paint, and character accuracy that fits beautifully into a 6-inch-style display. Revoltech goes even harder on articulation — sometimes almost absurdly hard — but if you want a figure that can actually hit those dramatic comic-book poses without looking like it’s fighting its own joints, that line has a real following.
That’s the pocket of the market boutique brands are quietly winning. Not the casual buyer. Not the parent in the aisle. The collector who looks at a McFarlane figure and says, "I like it, but I need better scale, better engineering, or better materials than this."
So yeah — McFarlane is still important. It’s still the most visible collector-focused DC line at retail. But there’s a growing part of the hobby that sees it as the middle ground now, not the finish line.
Will the Value of Your McFarlane Collection Go Up?
I’m not a financial advisor: I’m a guy who spends too much time thinking about plastic superheroes: but history tells us a very specific story. When a long-running, highly detailed line like DC Multiverse ends, the "Gold Label" exclusives and the niche characters tend to skyrocket.
Think about it. If Mattel takes over, they are going to "reset" the line. They’ll start with the basics: Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman. It will be years before they get back to the obscure, beautiful weirdness of Fire and Ice 2-packs or specialized variants like the Dark Detective Batman.
If you have those figures now: keep them mint. If you don't, now is the time to hunt. Because once the Mattel "Core" figures are the only thing on the pegs, the McFarlane era is going to be remembered as the "Golden Age of Detail" for DC fans.
The "Build-A-Figure" Strategy
One thing we specialize in here at Grown Up Kids is the BAF (Build-A-Figure) sets. We know the struggle: you want the big guy, the centerpiece, but you have to track down six different figures to get all the pieces. It’s a hunt, and it’s exhausting.
McFarlane has mastered this. Whether it’s a giant Bane or a hulking Darkseid, the BAF system keeps the community talking. Mattel used to do this well with their "Collect and Connect" figures, but in their recent wrestling and "kid" lines, they’ve moved away from it in favor of simpler packaging.
If Mattel kills the BAF strategy to save on production costs, the collector market is going to feel it. That "scrappy" hunt is part of the fun! It's why we curate complete sets of BAF waves whenever we can: to save you the headache of finding that one missing left leg in a dusty warehouse somewhere.
A Human-First Approach to Collecting
We aren't a faceless corporation like Target or Amazon. We’re a small team of enthusiasts who actually care if the corner of your box is dinged. We get the "why" behind your collection: it’s not just about spending money; it’s about reclaiming a piece of your youth.
When you buy a DC Multiverse figure from us, you're buying from someone who knows the difference between a "Standard" release and a "Gold Label" exclusive. We price based on what’s fair, what’s rare, and what we’d pay ourselves.
As the "DC Great Divide" approaches, our promise to you is simple: We are staying in the collector lane.
Let Mattel have the kids' aisle. Let them flood the shelves with $12 basic figures that will end up in a yard sale in two years. We’re going to keep focusing on the premium pieces: the stuff with the textures, the 22 points of articulation, and the character choices that make you say, "I can't believe they actually made a figure of that."
One Last Thing That Should Make Collectors Nervous
I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t skeptical about Mattel handling high-quality face sculpts on an "adult collector" DC line.
Because — and let’s just say this plainly — if you’ve seen some of the recent Mattel wrestling figure head sculpts, you have every right to be very scared. Some of them look great. Some of them look like a witness sketch done from memory after three energy drinks and no sleep.
That’s the part that keeps nagging at me. DC collectors are not forgiving about faces. Batman can have the best cape in the world, but if the expression looks off, the whole figure is cooked. Superman especially lives or dies on the portrait. Wonder Woman too. These are not characters you can get away with making look vaguely correct.
So while Mattel absolutely has the manufacturing muscle, I think the real question is whether they can deliver collector-level likenesses consistently — not just once in a promo shot, but wave after wave, release after release.
Because if they can’t, then all this talk about the "adult collector" lane starts sounding real flimsy, real fast. Are we headed toward a true premium revival — or are we just circling back to uncanny valley in nicer packaging? That’s the question.
So, What’s Your Move?
Are you a "completionist" who needs every McFarlane figure before the 2026 shift? Or are you cautiously optimistic that Mattel might bring back the 6-inch scale glory days?
I want to hear from you. Seriously. Reach out to us on our Contact Page or leave a comment if you see us on social media. This is a conversation, not just a transaction. We’re all trying to navigate this weird world of plastic and licensing together.
In the meantime, keep your shelves clean, your capes crisp, and remember: you're never too old for the "cool stuff."
Stay nostalgic,
The Grown Up Kids Team
0 comments